The Iditarod Is Brutal to Dogs

Tue, Jan 15, 2008

Ecology

Environmental Graffiti Will be Changing Dramatically Soon. Get a Sneak Preview By Signing Up Here.

A few days ago we wrote an article about how global warming was affecting the annual Iditarod dog sled race.

dog
A musher stays in his sled while his dogs drag an unconscious or dead sled dog

One of our readers left a very detailed and interesting response to the article which brought the plight of the Iditarod sled dogs to our attention. We felt her words needed a bit more attention than they’d get posted as a comment on the bottom of on of our articles, so we’ve decided to post it here:

“The most important thing anyone should know about the Iditarod is that the race is terribly cruel to dogs. For the facts, visit the Sled Dog Action Coalition website, http://www.helpsleddogs.org.

Here’s a short list of what happens to the dogs during the Iditarod: death, paralysis, penile frostbite, bleeding ulcers, bloody diarrhea, lung damage, pneumonia, ruptured discs, viral diseases, broken bones, torn muscles and tendons, vomiting, hypothermia, sprains, fur loss, broken teeth, torn footpads and anemia.

At least 133 dogs have died in the Iditarod. There is no official count of dog deaths available for the race’s early years. In “WinterDance: the Fine Madness of Running the Iditarod,” a nonfiction book, Gary Paulsen describes witnessing an Iditarod musher brutally kicking a dog to death during the race. He wrote, “All the time he was kicking the dog. Not with the imprecision of anger, the kicks, not kicks to match his rage but aimed, clinical vicious kicks. Kicks meant to hurt deeply, to cause serious injury. Kicks meant to kill.”

Causes of death have also included strangulation in towlines, internal hemorrhaging after being gouged by a sled, liver injury, heart failure, and pneumonia. “Sudden death” and “external myopathy,” a fatal condition in which a dog’s muscles and organs deteriorate during extreme or prolonged exercise, have also occurred. The 1976 Iditarod winner, Jerry Riley, was accused of striking his dog with a snow hook (a large, sharp and heavy metal claw). In 1996, one of Rick Swenson’s dogs died while he mushed his team through waist-deep water and ice. The Iditarod Trail Committee banned both mushers from the race but later reinstated them. In many states these incidents would be considered animal cruelty. Swenson is now on the Iditarod Board of Directors.

In the 2001 Iditarod, a sick dog was sent to a prison to be cared for by inmates and received no veterinary care. He was chained up in the cold and died. Another dog died by suffocating on his own vomit.

No one knows how many dogs die in training or after the race each year.

On average, 53 percent of the dogs who start the race do not make it across the finish line. According to a report published in the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, of those who do cross, 81 percent have lung damage. A report published in the Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine said that 61 percent of the dogs who finish the Iditarod have ulcers versus zero percent pre-race.

Tom Classen, retired Air Force colonel and Alaskan resident for over 40 years, tells us that the dogs are beaten into submission:

“They’ve had the hell beaten out of them.” “You don’t just whisper into their ears, ‘OK, stand there until I tell you to run like the devil.’ They understand one thing: a beating. These dogs are beaten into submission the same way elephants are trained for a circus. The mushers will deny it. And you know what? They are all lying.” -USA Today, March 3, 2000 in Jon Saraceno’s column

Beatings and whippings are common. Jim Welch says in his book Speed Mushing Manual, “I heard one highly respected [sled dog] driver once state that “‘Alaskans like the kind of dog they can beat on.’” “Nagging a dog team is cruel and ineffective…A training device such as a whip is not cruel at all but is effective.” “It is a common training device in use among dog mushers…A whip is a very humane training tool.”

During the 2007 Iditarod, eyewitnesses reported that musher Ramy Brooks kicked, punched and beat his dogs with a ski pole and a chain. Brooks admitted to hitting his dogs with a wooden trail marker when they refused to run. The Iditarod Trail Committee suspended Brooks for two years, but only for the actions he admitted. By ignoring eyewitness accounts, the Iditarod encouraged animal abuse. When mushers know that eyewitness accounts will be disregarded, they are more likely to hurt their dogs and lie about it later.

Mushers believe in “culling” or killing unwanted dogs, including puppies. Many dogs who are permanently disabled in the Iditarod, or who are unwanted for any reason, are killed with a shot to the head, dragged or clubbed to death. “On-going cruelty is the law of many dog lots. Dogs are clubbed with baseball bats and if they don’t pull are dragged to death in harnesses…..” wrote Alaskan Mike Cranford in an article for Alaska’s Bush Blade Newspaper (March, 2000).

Jon Saraceno wrote in his March 3, 2000 column in USA Today, “He [Colonel Tom Classen] confirmed dog beatings and far worse. Like starving dogs to maintain their most advantageous racing weight. Skinning them to make mittens. Or dragging them to their death.”

The Iditarod, with its history of abuse, could not be legally held in many states, because doing so would violate animal cruelty laws.

Iditarod administrators promote the race as a commemoration of sled dogs saving the children of Nome by bringing diphtheria serum from Anchorage in 1925. However, the co-founder of the Iditarod, Dorothy Page, said the race was not established to honor the sled drivers and dogs who carried the serum. In fact, 600 miles of this serum delivery was done by train and the other half was done by dogs running in relays, with no dog running over 100 miles. This isn’t anything like the Iditarod.

The race has led to the proliferation of horrific dog kennels in which the dogs are treated very cruelly. Many kennels have over 100 dogs and some have as many as 200. It is standard for the dogs to spend their entire lives outside tethered to metal chains that can be as short as four feet long. In 1997 the United States Department of Agriculture determined that the tethering of dogs was inhumane and not in the animals’ best interests. The chaining of dogs as a primary means of enclosure is prohibited in all cases where federal law applies. A dog who is permanently tethered is forced to urinate and defecate where he sleeps, which conflicts with his natural instinct to eliminate away from his living area.

Iditarod dogs are prisoners of abuse.

Sincerely,
Margery Glickman
Sled Dog Action Coalition, http://www.helpsleddogs.org”

If you want to find out all the latest news on animals and their proper treatment, why not subcribe to our RSS feed, we’ll even throw in a free album.

, , , , , , , ,

You Might Also Like Our Friends' Posts From the Intertubes

“The only true currency in this bankrupt world is what you share with someone else.”


This post was written by:

Chris - who has written 598 posts on Environmental Graffiti.

Chris (50% English, 50% Italian) is the evil overlord and creator of Environmental Graffiti. When he's not battling those pesky Jedi Knights, he can be found blogging about weird and wonderful environmental news. It's sort of becoming a full time job...he is quite surprised!

Contact the author

16 Comments For This Post

Leave a Reply

  1. Margery Glickman Says:

    Thank you for helping the Iditarod dogs by republishing my response. It’s important that people learn the truth about this cruel race.

    Sincerely,
    Margery Glickman
    Sled Dog Action Coalition, http://www.helpsleddogs.org

  2. Alice White Says:

    As a dog musher and sled dog fan, I take issue with the Sled Dog Action Coalition. My experience in the world of sled dog sports contradicts the image that is presented on the SDAC website. Every musher I have met has shown great care and compassion for his or her dogs and the dogs have what can only be described as passion for running.

    I am willing to listen to the arguments of those opposing sled dog sports (and I would even be willing to print them in a sled dog newsletter I write except that I have never gotten any response from the SDAC when I requested an interview) but they don’t stand up to what I have seen and experienced.

    The black and white photo with the caption that the dog is being dragged has no verification. Several times I have asked the Sled Dog Action Coalition for information on the picture, and they have refused to give anything out. I have heard several stories – one saying that the team was stopped and the dog was simply lying down, another saying the “dog” was actually a piece of black plastic and even that the photo was a downright fake. It might not be but without verification, we don’t know.

    In any case, I don’t know any mushers who would abuse or mistreat their dogs – and I am the first to condemn animal cruelty! Much of the “information” presented by the Sled Dog Action Coalition is open to debate and some has been presented out of context. I feel that what are rare occurrences in the sled dog world have been unfairly portrayed as the norm.

    I don’t deny that there have been rare cases of abuse in sled dog sports. There have also been cases of “pet-owners” abusing their dogs. Are you against pets?

    Before you condemn dog mushing and the Iditarod, why not get out and meet some mushers. Go to a sled dog race and meet some dogs. Visit a kennel. I think you’ll find that most mushers love dogs just as much as you.

    Thanks for your time,

    Alice White

    Dog & Sled – http://www.dx4solutions.com/dogandsled/

    Wolf Moon Dogsledding – http://sleddoggin.com/blogs/wolfmoonsleddog/

  3. monicaS Says:

    Thank you for an informative, if heartbreaking story. One of the worst forms abuse these dogs have to suffer is being perpetually chained in the ice and snow, often with only pitiful, broken down house for “shelter.” Sure, not all mushers are animal abusers, but overall, sled dogs suffer horrifically because “people have always done it that way.” Learn how these dogs – and any dogs – suffer if kept chained at http://www.dogsdeservebetter.org

  4. James Callaway Says:

    Margery Glickman has been running this defamatory campaign against mushers for at least the last 12 years. It works in her favor to tug the emotional heart strings of gullible people that don’t know the first thing about sled dogs or mushing. While she seems passionate in her view, she is completely misinformed. Before you swallow her “facts” do a little critical thinking of your own. Locate and talk with a musher. I believe you will come away with at the very least a more educated view of mushers and sled dogs.

  5. Dog Lover Says:

    Dog sled races are completely unnecessary and should be tested against federal and state animal cruelty laws immediately.

    The applicable criminal code for animal cruelty should put that task on the shoulders of the law enforcement and the state prosecutors.

  6. Cute Cat Pictures Says:

    This is very disheartening. If a human can be cruel to dogs like that, i wonder what he would do to his own children

  7. AlaskanMan Says:

    Guess what? Dogs LOVE to run. Really. I would invite any of you liberal do-gooders who have never lived in a rural environment to come to Alaska and witness the Iditarod race start. What you will see will astound you. Dogs chomping at the bit to get going…running. It is part of their pack mentality and they love to do it. And something else for all of you liberal weenies to consider: dog races are GREEN. That’s right! No carbon emissions, just a little methane. Contrary to popular belief, these dogs are not whipped or mistreated. These dogs are in much better physical shape than the average American housedog. What does the average dog do? Sit around all day holding in urine and feces waiting for their owner to return from their busy day. Then, they MIGHT get to go for a walk! These dogs live in the wilderness their whole lives. They get fed more higher nutrient diets than almost any dog in the world…then they get to excercise all day! Is that a bad life? I don’t think so.

    Seriously, don’t these people have more important issues to worry about? World War? Fuel Shortage? Global Warming? Maybe they just pick on this sport because it is easy to do. Come to Alaska and check it out for yourselves, tree huggers.

  8. Dolphin Says:

    I won’t pretend to know much about these dog-sledding races because I’ve never actually followed them. As a dog and over-all animal lover myself, I don’t support situations like the greyhound races, horse racing, wildlife kept in captivity in enclosed safaris, zoos, and in circuses, etc.

    What not only breaks my heart but absolutely enrages me, are the reports of animal abuse and cruelty. I’m a big believer in that if someone kicks a dog, treats it inhumanely, kills it in the manner that’s been written in this article, etc etc., then that human should be punished in the same manner he treated his animals.

    Radical maybe .. but perhaps the message would then be clear. Do unto others (including animals) as you’d have done unto you.

    Dolphin

  9. Josh Says:

    well it looks to me like the man in the sled is laying back and sleeping….so that would point towards that he doesnt have much care for what hes doing. like alice white said theres rare occurances where abuse happens but thats everywhere in the world.

  10. Jack Says:

    As a tree-hugging liberal myself I have always loved the thought of dog-sledding [if that's how it's called in the professional vernacular]. It seemed to me that the dogs actually enjoyed running. In that context I wouldn’t mind a race like that at all. It seems counter-intuitive to mistreat dogs when they are to engage in a high-performance athletic effort. How many marathon runners are getting the crap kicked out of them right before the race? That’s not going to work really well if they then have to exert themselves, right?

    By the same token it doesn’t make sense to hurt dogs before a race. Would anyone really hit a dog senseless and then be irate because it didn’t run very well? It doesn’t compute.

    Having said that I’m convinced that there will be characters out there who don’t think twice about hurting animals. After all, we think nothing about slaughtering our own kind by the thousands, we don’t even need a reason. That kind of personality is not going to be soft when it comes to mistreating animals.

    I’m not opposed to a race, even one as demanding as the Iditarod, where dogs are involved. I would hope, without being naive about it, that the dogs would be treated as valuable team members instead of meat bags that need to be bludgeoned into submission. Healthy competition is an outlet of aggression and it hones our skills. There is nothing wrong with that. On the contrary, we should do more of it, not less. But always with the clear understanding that it’s just competition and that nobody, man or beast, should suffer for someone else’s idea of ‘fun’ or ’sports’. Nobody is that important. No mere recreational activity justifies the suffering of those who could not choose whether they wanted to participate or not.

    In times where we had little or no choice it makes no sense to argue about survival or not. In times where we assume a higher level of civilization we have to use a higher standard of treating ourselves and those around us. Common courtesy if you will.

    I profoundly hope that the mushers love the spirit of competition and the companionship and the hard work of their dogs more than the need to assert their ego over their chattel. Misery comes natural to us, suffering is our greatest talent. Being good takes the hard work.

  11. Ryan Says:

    With absolutely no dog racing knowledge, and only knowing what is said in this article, responses, and dogs behaviour, it is hard to believe that dogs could not love running. The average north american house dog, spends all day just WAITING for that half-hour run, or sometimes in cities, only a walk. The question does not lie in whether a dog likes running, but more in how it likes being chained to a sled, and pulling for hours on end? Secondly, would be how the owners and trainers go about the training for an event such as this. In the spirit of compitition, and for the dogs sake, I hope they are loved as they should be..

  12. Tree Hugger Says:

    I’m from Kentucky and I know what happens to the horses that don’t make it to the next race because they are great runners so I’m sure Ms. Glickman’s account, while tugging at the heart strings, isn’t too far off. I also know what human athletes go through in order to “be the best”, so again, Js. Glickman’s account isn’t too unbelievable. If humans want to abuse themselves to be athletes and compete – fine, just leave the animals out of it – they don’t have a choice.

  13. Ralph Conatser Says:

    I was involved with the Iditarod Race for for over 25 years being the checker at Eagle Island on the southern route.
    I remember in 1977 the first time the race took the southern route, I saw a musher feeding his dogs butter, and I thought to myself these dogs are eating better than me and my family, for we use mareargine.
    There is some people that protest anything they don´t like.
    So my suggestion to them if they don`t like dog mushing shut up and stay home.

  14. spirit Says:

    RE: ALASKAMAN

    DUH!!!! Of course dogs love to run! I had an Alaskan Malamute for 18 years. But guess what? Dogs don’t want to be FORCED to run just so a human can be a celebrity, win a trophy and collect monies at the dog’s expense, and pain!!!!! Get a clue! Go RECREATIONAL mushing.

  15. ALASKANJRMUSHER Says:

    If you actually believe the Iditarod is cruel…there is no hope for you. You are listening to this person who lives in FLORIDA!!! Try listening to real ALASKANS and not crazy PETA supporters. I think the Iditarod is a totally brilliant race and I am planning on running it myself in 2012. As a Junior Iditarod finisher I can assure you that you CANNOT force these dogs to race. You can’t push a rope!!! I have volunteered for the Iditarod for the past 11 years and I can assure you that these dogs are not unhappy and as sickly and abused as the Sled Dog Action Coalition suggests. If you don’t want to come visit the race first hand stop commenting on how cruel it is!

  16. Shauna Says:

    i think that if you ever beat an animal nore a person you should have to pay the crime…I want to see you get your but out there and pull a 50 pound sled 1150 miles and be beaten till you do and be frozen to dealth in some of these dogs cases!!!!!
    -Shauna

ss_blog_claim=68ded206efcf0b5d4bf955123f191aba