Tue, Apr 15, 2008
This would be funny if it wasn’t both dangerous and disgusting: scientists using federal grant money spread sludge made of processed human waste over the yard of nine families in a poor, largely African-American section of Baltimore.
![]()
Image from Bukutgirl on Flickr
The research, which was designed to mitigate long-term risks from lead-based paint, was largely carried out without the understanding of the families involved, who were paid for their troubles with new lawns and food coupons.
The federal government has maintained for years that the sludge (which is what’s left after several rounds of treatment at one of the nation’s 16,500 wastewater treatment facilities) is nontoxic to humans. However, there’s little excuse for why this experiment was carried out only in poor, minority neighborhoods (a sister project was undertaken in East St. Louis, IL).
Despite that history, there have been doubts about the sludge: the EPA Inspector General called the agency stance on it into doubt in 2002, demanding more research.
The families in the experiment were simply lied to, and told that the fertilizer was store-bought, and that their children were at risk to lead poisoning without it. There has been no medical follow-up since the end of the project.
Environmental Graffiti is up for four bloggers’ choice awards. You can vote for us for best entertainment blog, best blog of all time, best geek blog and best animal blogger.
If you want to find out all the latest news on the environment, why not subscribe to our RSS feed? We’ll even throw in a free album.
April 15th, 2008 at 7:58 pm
You might want to have a read of the response to this article in case it is worth rethinking the tone of yours. It’s difficult, isn’t it, to know which way to go on this story.
April 16th, 2008 at 2:54 am
I think it is more of a socio-economic issue rather than a racial thing. When I lived in Virginia in the ’90’s studies showed that lead paint was predominantly in poorer neighborhoods. These areas were also invariably predominantly African American.
If you look at the effects in child development due to exposure to lead it is definitely a serious issue that needs to be solved.